INTRODUCTION
A woman in a remote Nigerian community loses her land. A young man is arrested but cannot afford a lawyer. A worker is unlawfully dismissed but does not know where to seek help. For each, the law may exist on paper, yet justice remains beyond reach.
Access to justice is not merely the existence of courts and legal rights; it is the ability to understand those rights, obtain assistance, participate meaningfully in proceedings and secure a timely remedy. In Nigeria, cost, distance, delay, inadequate legal information and limited legal aid continue to obstruct this access.
Technology offers a powerful opportunity to change this through e-filing, digital legal aid, mobile legal information, virtual hearings, online dispute resolution and artificial intelligence.
This article argues that technology can significantly narrow Nigeria’s access-to-justice gap, but only when deployed as an inclusive, secure and human-centred tool. Without affordable connectivity, digital literacy, data protection and non-digital alternatives, the technology intended to build a bridge to justice may instead become another gatekeeper.
ACCESS TO JUSTICE AS A CONSTITUTIONAL PROMISE
Access to justice is closely connected to the rule of law. A right that cannot be explained, claimed or enforced offers little protection to the person who possesses it. The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 provides the constitutional foundation for meaningful access to justice.
Section 36(1) guarantees a fair hearing within a reasonable time before an independent and impartial court or tribunal established by law, while section 6 vests judicial powers in the courts established for the Federation and the States.[1] These guarantees are meaningful only when people can realistically approach the institutions responsible for enforcing them.
The courts have consistently treated fair hearing as a substantive constitutional safeguard rather than a procedural ornament, as demonstrated in Igwe v State[2]
Also, the Legal Aid Act 2011 recognises the need to provide legal aid, legal advice and access to justice to persons who lack adequate resources.[3]
THE BARRIERS OF THE TRADITIONAL SYSTEM
The first two barriers are cost and geography. Litigation requires more than a lawyer’s professional fee; litigants may incur transport expenses, documentation and filing costs, communication charges, and lost income from repeated court attendance. Geography compounds the problem: with legal services and courts concentrated largely in urban centres, distance can make justice practically inaccessible to Nigerians in rural and hard-to-reach communities.
The third barrier is delay. Paper-based filing, fragmented records, manual scheduling and poor coordination between justice institutions can prolong proceedings. Delay affects both claimants and defendants. This concern has constitutional significance.
Section 36(1) expressly requires civil rights and obligations to be determined within a reasonable time, while section 294(1) requires constitutionally established courts to deliver decisions within 90 days after final addresses.
Nigerian appellate courts have repeatedly recognised the importance of timely adjudication, although delay does not automatically nullify a judgment unless it occasions a miscarriage of justice[4]
Another barrier is limited legal information and language accessibility. Many citizens are unsure whether their problems require civil or criminal remedies, customary-law processes, labour complaints or mediation. Where legal procedures are communicated only in technical English, the justice system may be formally open but functionally inaccessible to many Nigerians.
WHAT TECHNOLOGY CAN CHANGE
- Legal Information for Ordinary Citizens
A multilingual digital platform could provide plain-language and accessible guidance on common legal problems, including unlawful dismissal, domestic violence, land and tenancy disputes, arrest and small claims. Audio, local-language content and short videos would make legal information accessible to users who may struggle with legislation and procedural rules.
The platform should serve as a first point of legal orientation, with clear referrals to qualified lawyers or legal-aid providers where individualised advice or representation is required.
- Digital legal aid and referral
The Legal Aid Council and civil-society organisations could use digital platforms to register applications, conduct preliminary assessments and refer eligible persons to lawyers or legal clinics. This would complement rather than replace the statutory mandate of the Legal Aid Council to facilitate legal aid for persons entitled to it under the Legal Aid Act 2011.[5]
A well-designed system could register complaints, identify urgent cases such as detention or eviction, assess eligibility for legal aid, refer users to nearby legal-service providers and track resolution or escalation. However, digital registration must not become a condition for receiving assistance. Those without smartphones should have equal access through toll-free lines, USSD, community centres or assisted-digital kiosks.
- E-filing and case tracking
E-filing, electronic case-tracking, virtual hearing and dispute resolution can reduce travel, administrative costs and delay, particularly in procedural, low-value and suitable civil matters. The National Judicial Institute has identified e-filing, online case tracking, digital scheduling and online access to judgments as high-value services capable of reducing cost, improving transparency and easing administrative burdens.[6]
Virtual hearings may be useful for procedural applications, case management conferences, uncontested matters and situations where physical attendance would impose disproportionate hardship. They may also assist persons who are ill, detained, living far from the court or unable to afford repeated travel.
Nigerian courts have also recognised the relationship between technological procedure and access to justice. In Tyoh & Ors v Government of Benue State & Anor.[7] A person who loses a case because of poor connectivity has not received meaningful access to justice. Nigeria’s COVID-19 experience showed that digital justice is practicable, but reform must simplify procedures and focus on measurable outcomes.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AS AN ASSISTANT, NOT A JUDGE
Artificial intelligence can support legal research, document classification, translation, transcription, case scheduling and legal-aid triage. However, it is not an infallible source of law. AI may generate inaccurate authorities, misunderstand facts or reproduce bias, with errors potentially affecting liberty, property and other fundamental interests. AI should therefore assist, not replace, judges, lawyers and legal-aid providers.
Its use in justice administration must remain subject to human oversight, transparency, auditability and mechanisms for challenging erroneous outputs. The principle is simple: AI may support legal judgment, but it must not replace legal responsibility.
Yet, the strongest argument against an uncritical celebration of technology is that not everyone can access it. Digital justice requires electricity, devices, affordable data, network coverage, digital literacy and accessible language.
Nigeria’s broadband penetration remains below the national target, while the cost of connectivity and devices continues to limit meaningful access. If courts move entirely online without alternatives, the poorest and most vulnerable litigants may be excluded first, transforming technology from a bridge into a gatekeeper.
The solution is not to reject digital justice, but to make it inclusive. Courts and legal-aid institutions should retain physical help desks, telephone services and community-based assistance, while digital platforms should support low-bandwidth access, basic mobile phones, audio and local-language options. Technology should expand the doorway to justice, not create another door that the poor cannot open.
PRIVACY, SECURITY AND TRUST
Legal information can be highly sensitive, involving criminal allegations, family disputes, finances, children and victims of violence. Digitising such information therefore creates risks of unauthorised access, identity theft and public exposure.
The Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023 provides safeguards based on principles including lawfulness, transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation and security.[8] Digital justice systems must therefore collect only necessary information, restrict access and protect records.
The Constitution also protects privacy under section 37, requiring digital accessibility to be pursued without sacrificing users’ privacy rights. Appropriate safeguards should include encryption, secure authentication, access controls and breach-response mechanisms. Privacy must not be treated as an obstacle to innovation; it is a condition of trust. A victim will not seek digital assistance if the technology intended to provide justice exposes their identity or complaint.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Nigeria should:
- Adopt a coordinated digital-justice framework linking key justice institutions and legal-aid providers.
- Provide accessible, multilingual legal information and digital legal-aid services.
- Prioritise practical tools such as e-filing, case tracking, electronic notifications, digital judgments and secure records.
- Ensure responsible AI use, with human oversight and accountability for all AI-assisted decisions.
- Establish assisted digital-justice centres while preserving physical and telephone alternatives for those without digital access.
Success should be measured by reduced cost, delay and exclusion, not technological sophistication.
CONCLUSION
Technology can significantly narrow Nigeria’s access-to-justice gap, but it cannot do so alone. A website cannot cure poverty; an algorithm cannot replace judicial empathy; and a virtual courtroom cannot compensate for absent infrastructure. Its value lies in reducing the cost, distance and delay that prevent people from enforcing their rights.
Nigeria should therefore pursue not merely a digital justice system, but one that is accessible, affordable, secure, inclusive and humane. Technology should bring the law closer to the citizen, not place another screen between the citizen and justice.
If properly designed and responsibly governed, technology can transform legal rights from promises on paper into remedies within reach. But the ultimate measure of digital justice is not how advanced the technology is; it is whether the person who needs justice most can actually reach it.
References:
[1] Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, ss 6 and 36(1).
[2] In Igwe v. State (2022) 1 NWLR (pt. 1810) 111, the Supreme Court emphasised that fair hearing operates for both parties and requires a judicial process that treats the competing parties fairly.
[3] Legal Aid Act 2011, Act No 17, ss 1, 8 and 17, Federal Republic of Nigeria Official Gazette No 66, 15 June 2011 https://archive.gazettes.africa/archive/ng/2011/ng-government-gazette-dated-2011-06-15-no-66.pdf accessed 30 August 2026. (This is important because poverty is not merely an economic condition; it can become a legal disability. A person may have a valid claim but be unable to pay for transportation, legal representation, filing fees, documentation or repeated attendance at court.)
[4] Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, ss 36(1), 294(1) and (5); Dennis Akoma & Anor v Obi Osenwokwu & Ors (2014) SC.102/2005.
[5] Legal Aid Act 2011, ss 1, 7–10.
[6] A A Dahiru, ‘Enhancing Public Access to Justice Through Digital Tools: Empowering Citizens with Technology-Driven Legal Services’ (paper presented at the National Workshop for Information and Communication Technology Staff, National Judicial Institute, 7–9 April 2025) 2–5 https://nji.gov.ng/assets/publication/Session-5-Enhancing-Public-Access-to-Justice-Through-Digital-Tools_NJI_by_AADahiru.pdf accessed 30 August 2026.
[7] In Tyoh & Ors v Government of Benue State & Anor (2020) LPELR – 49961 (CA), the Court of Appeal considered the use of modern technological means in judicial proceedings, while more recent decisions have continued to recognise virtual hearings as a legitimate procedural option where the circumstances justify them.
[8] The Nigeria Data Protection Act 2023, Act No. 37, S. 24
About the Author
Oluwaleye Adedoyin Grace, LLB. (Hons.)[email protected] or 08106289069
